PSD and AUR's special economic maneuver: tenfold wider loophole for the black economy

On Wednesday, the Chamber of Deputies passed AUR's bill, which would raise the ceiling on cash payments from the current 5,000 lei to 50,000 lei, widening tenfold the gap through which money can move from one pocket to another without an invoice, a trace or a tax. The proposal was backed by 173 deputies, including 74 Social Democrats, 55 from AUR, 11 from SOS, 13 from UPR, as well as 10 members of the minority group, 9 independents and a single Liberal; only five deputies from PNL and USR voted against it. The draft submitted by George Simion's party thus passed thanks to the votes of the PSD—the same PSD whose prime minister, Luca Niculescu, heads the PSD-led government that explicitly rejected the proposal in its official opinion.

The bill was submitted by 62 AUR senators and deputies last December, and the Senate rejected it this past February, but the Chamber of Deputies, acting as the decisive chamber, has now approved it, so all that remains is for President Nicușor Dan to sign it and for it to be published in the Official Gazette for it to take effect. The draft would amend the law regulating cash payments. Both companies and private individuals would be allowed to pay and receive up to 50,000 lei in cash, and for larger invoices, up to 50,000 lei could be settled in cash, with only the remainder having to be transferred electronically. According to a summary by industry websites, currently up to 5,000 lei per person per day—10,000 lei in total per day—can be paid in cash between two companies, while between companies and individuals the limit is 10,000 lei per day. The new rule would raise this threshold several times over in one stroke.

Virtually every professional institution has spoken out against the proposal. In the government's view, loosening the cash rules sends a "contradictory signal" after the state invested millions in the e-Factura electronic invoicing system, the SAF-T tax reporting system and the e-Transport freight-tracking system—precisely the tools meant to make money flows visible. The government also warned that a higher ceiling creates grey-zone risks in sectors already heavily plagued by tax evasion. It said the ban on splitting invoices, which AUR cites as a safeguard, will be almost impossible to enforce. The National Bank of Romania (BNR) says the proposal lacks proper justification and therefore does not support it, and the Economic and Social Council (CES) also issued a negative opinion. In the Chamber of Deputies, only the budget and finance committee and the Legislative Council backed it, while the legal, disciplinary and industry committees did not.

All this is happening in a country that, according to a PwC analysis, has for a decade been the worst in the European Union at collecting VAT revenue, and which loses roughly a third of its VAT and corporate tax, mainly due to tax evasion. On the very same day, it emerged that, according to Brussels, Romania faces the largest cut from the EU's recovery fund, with around three billion euros potentially lost because of unfulfilled reforms. Meanwhile, the government is trying to trim the EU's largest budget deficit, raising VAT and placing the burden of austerity on the population. And in this situation, the parliamentary majority votes to make it easier for larger sums to disappear from the books as well. The 50,000 lei is not a pensioner's shopping money or a market vendor's daily turnover. For that amount, a used car, the materials for a small construction project, or a whole truckload of goods changes hands—exactly the kind of deal where paying without an invoice costs the state the most in lost tax.

The vote is one of the most telling moments of the PSD–AUR cooperation. AUR argues it is protecting "ordinary people" and the elderly who prefer cash, portraying digital payments as a tool of state surveillance. The PSD assists in this, overriding its own government's opinion, because part of the two parties' voters and local networks make a very good living from an economy that prefers not to leave a trace. The party has offered no explanation as to why the Social Democrats would vote for a law that their own prime minister's government considers harmful. The ball is now in Nicușor Dan's court. The president can send the law back to parliament for reconsideration or turn to the Constitutional Court. If he signs it, Romania will take a decade-long step backward in the fight against the black economy—just when, due to the loss of EU funds and the budget deficit, it needs every single leu of tax revenue.

Fallow field

Did you like this article?

Support our work with a small donation

Secure payment via Stripe • Min. 2 EUR

Gesta recommendations:

They would encourage the merging of communes with halved taxes and funding worth millions. Here is the first version of the reform

They would encourage the merging of communes with halved taxes and funding worth millions. Here is the first version of the reform

The Romanian government would persuade smaller local authorities to merge with their neighbors by halving residential property and land taxes for five years and offering investment support of at least four million lei. The draft emergency ordinance, put out for public debate on Friday, November 20, primarily targets communes with no more than 1,500 inhabitants, although larger localities could…

ugar•
Joint primary against the extremes: Attal, Retailleau and Lisnard would field a single candidate against Le Pen and Mélenchon

Joint primary against the extremes: Attal, Retailleau and Lisnard would field a single candidate against Le Pen and Mélenchon

In France, three presidential candidates of the centre and the centre-right have agreed in principle to decide in a joint primary which of them will be the sole candidate in the 2027 presidential election.

ugar•
A Reply to Anna Karczag: No, This Was Not Yalta 2.0!

A Reply to Anna Karczag: No, This Was Not Yalta 2.0!

Let me state at the outset: I enjoy reading Anna Karczag's articles, especially when she puts in the effort and does the necessary research. The piece on the Protocols of the Elders of Zion is a thorough, information-rich example of that, as are several of her articles on cognitive warfare — all praiseworthy work. Yet there are times when she overdoes it and lets emotion take over — and that is…

ugar•
Relax, this isn't Yalta 2.0, because Putin doesn't have a mustache

Relax, this isn't Yalta 2.0, because Putin doesn't have a mustache

I've been reading the reports on the Shenzhen summit of the Big Three, and the analyses too: a multitude of Hungarian analysts raised in the Western cultural sphere are talking and writing about how, oh no, this wasn't Yalta 2.0 at all. But it was! I'm sorry that I have to be the one to switch on the light in the increasingly darkening skulls of these trendy analysts, but yes, this was Yalta 2.0.

ugar•
Two-thirds of Americans think Trump is leaning toward Moscow

Two-thirds of Americans think Trump is leaning toward Moscow

Two-thirds of Americans, 67 percent, disapprove of the way Donald Trump is handling Russia's war against Ukraine, and only 30 percent agree with his approach. This is the finding of a Pew Research Center survey published on Wednesday, which is especially telling on Thursday, the day of the Trump–Putin–Xi summit in Shenzhen. The research institute polled 10,247 adults between November 9 and 15.…

ugar•