Migrant deportation, first step: Europe wants to send to Rwanda those who are supposed to leave but somehow always stay

Five EU countries are negotiating with Rwanda about setting up a centre to which foreigners who no longer have the right to stay in Europe, but who cannot be sent back to their home countries, would be transferred. The programme, planned for 2027, seeks an answer to a real problem, since an unenforceable deportation order sooner or later turns into a caricature of the rule of law — but that does not mean everything is solved simply because European governments find a more distant country on the map.

Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands announced on November 16 that, together with Rwanda, they are preparing a so-called return centre, which could initially accommodate around a hundred single adult men at a time. Although some reports have already presented the plan as a finalized agreement, the statements issued by the participating governments so far speak only of the start of negotiations and the drafting of conditions — meaning the political will exists, but the details needed for a functioning institution are still missing.

The centre could take in people who are not entitled to international protection and have no residence status, yet whose departure could still not be arranged. According to the plans, they would be housed in an open facility with access to basic services, and would later either settle in Rwanda or return home once the conditions for that are in place. Rwandan Interior Minister Vincent Biruta called this a second chance, and the funding of the programme would fall essentially to the five European states, although no final figures on the costs have been announced yet.

It is hard to dispute the part of the European governments' argument that an asylum system only works if rejection also has consequences. According to Austrian Chancellor Christian Stocker, the whole procedure loses its meaning if even those who have no right to stay cannot be removed, while Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen justified the initiative by citing the need to preserve social cohesion. German figures illustrate the scale of the problem: at the end of 2025, about 230,000 foreigners were under an obligation to leave the country, while in that same year fewer than 23,000 deportations were actually carried out. The two figures do not measure the same group or the same period, so a simple enforcement rate cannot be calculated from them, but they still clearly show the sheer mass of stalled cases.

The legal framework for the Rwandan solution would be provided by the EU's new return regulation, which ties agreements with third countries to certain conditions and does not allow anyone to be exposed to persecution or serious abuse. International organizations are also meant to play a role in the planned monitoring, but the involvement of the UN Refugee Agency so far means only advice and consultation, not an advance guarantee that everything will be fine. This is precisely where the harder debate begins, because Rwanda's human rights record can hardly be called reassuring. Freedom House gave the country seven points out of forty for political rights and fourteen points out of sixty for civil liberties, classifying it as not free, and the leadership in Kigali has also been criticized at UN human rights forums over the persecution of opposition figures, journalists and activists. Rwanda rejects these accusations, but Amnesty International fears that the European agreement will channel people to a place where it will be far harder to assert their rights.

Céline Mias, the EU director of the Danish Refugee Council, also objects that the people concerned would be taken to a country with which they have no connection whatsoever. The UK Supreme Court already blocked a Rwanda scheme in 2023, because it was not convinced that people sent there would not later be forwarded on to countries where they would face the threat of persecution; the current plan, however, differs from the British model, which would have also outsourced the processing of asylum claims that had not yet been assessed. According to Oxford migration researcher Peter W. Walsh, a 2027 launch is still an ambitious undertaking, and at the outset at most a smaller pilot programme can be expected.

Unworkable procedures can also have consequences for public safety, as the 2024 attack in Solingen demonstrated in particularly grave fashion. The Syrian man who killed three people and had joined the Islamic State was supposed to have been transferred to Bulgaria earlier, but the measure fell through, and once the processing deadline expired, Germany became responsible for his asylum claim. This clearly shows that a state cannot simply shrug off the enforcement of its own decisions. Europe has the right to protect its borders and to enforce the rules on residence, just as it is a legitimate expectation that the protection reserved for those who are genuinely persecuted should not turn into an endlessly extendable detour. The value of the Rwanda plan will therefore depend on whether it results in an enforceable, verifiable system, or whether all that happens is that Europe's helplessness is exported to Africa along with a plane ticket.

Ugar

Did you like this article?

Support our work with a small donation

Secure payment via Stripe • Min. 2 EUR

Gesta recommendations:

Trump wants peace by January, his wife is already dreaming of a Christmas ceasefire, meanwhile Ukrainians are dying

Trump wants peace by January, his wife is already dreaming of a Christmas ceasefire, meanwhile Ukrainians are dying

The Trump administration wants to close the Russian-Ukrainian peace deal by early January, before the new, Democratic-led Congress gets down to work, according to Financial Times. Melania Trump, meanwhile, is talking about the possibility of a ceasefire before Christmas, even as Moscow continues to reject the guarantees that would give Ukraine real protection against another Russian attack.…

ugar•
Raed Arafat has been indicted. The military prosecutor's office is charging him with complicity in smuggling

Raed Arafat has been indicted. The military prosecutor's office is charging him with complicity in smuggling

Raed Arafat is being prosecuted over the import into Romania of a rescue helicopter that was provided to replace an aircraft lost in a tragedy. The head of the Department for Emergency Situations (DSU) says an attempt is being made to retroactively turn an open, official procedure into a crime, while prosecutors claim that customs clearance was never completed and that more than four million lei…

ugar•
Bolojan and his party are also proposing an administrative reform, plus a reduction in the number of parliament seats

Bolojan and his party are also proposing an administrative reform, plus a reduction in the number of parliament seats

Ilie Bolojan has promised the PNL's position on administrative reform for early December, while the Liberals and the USR have almost finished drafting a joint proposal on reducing the size of parliament. According to the former prime minister, the government's announcements so far do not reveal a sufficiently well-developed reorganization, because merging two poor communes under a single name…

ugar•
Trump already threatens Democrats with veto

Trump already threatens Democrats with veto

Donald Trump did not waste much time explaining what he had learned from the results of the midterm elections, instead announcing the tool he will use to keep the Democratic legislative majority taking office in January in check. He praised the presidential veto as an extraordinary power that, in his view, can force his opponents to negotiate, and for Ukraine the decisive question will be whether…

ugar•
Consulting pays well around Trump: Romanian public money also surfaces among Jason Miller's millions

Consulting pays well around Trump: Romanian public money also surfaces among Jason Miller's millions

A child-support lawsuit revealed just how dramatically the business revenue of Donald Trump's longtime adviser has jumped, while among the clients paying for his Washington connections, Romania has also appeared. Jason Miller's companies collected about fifteen million dollars in a single year, yet the Cotroceni Palace still will not disclose exactly what the Romanian state is getting for the…

ugar•