The new government has barely taken office, and it's already planning a special energy tax

The Romanian government wants to curb the consequences of expensive energy with yet another special tax: consumers would be supported with money collected from energy producers. Help is needed, but the plan so far doesn't make clear how it would prevent the new burden from being passed back, at least partly, into prices. What's more, the reports don't even make it entirely clear exactly who would receive support from the revenue.

The new government had barely settled in when the well-worn tool of Romanian economic policy resurfaced: another tax. On November 16, Energy Minister Dumitru Chisăliță said a temporary special tax was being prepared for electricity producers, which would remain in force until April 1, 2027 at the latest. According to the minister, this would be a response to the currently high energy prices and would ease the consequences of the price increases. For now, it's only a planned measure: the statements don't reveal the tax rate, the exact tax base, or the date of introduction. Chisăliță indicated, however, that all producers could be affected regardless of the technology used, meaning that companies generating renewable energy might not necessarily be exempt either.

The picture is less consistent when it comes to how the revenue would be used. G4Media and Economedia write about support for vulnerable consumers, while Profit.ro's detailed report describes a tax-credit-based system intended not for household consumers. According to the minister's quoted explanation, support would go to entities that have been seriously affected by rising energy prices while also taking steps to reduce their consumption, improve their energy efficiency, or set up their own energy supply. This mainly means support for businesses, not direct help for households in need.

Regardless of this, reforming household support is also on the agenda. On November 10, Chisăliță said the government wants to launch a new support scheme for vulnerable consumers starting January 1, 2027, while support intended for non-household consumers could appear as early as December. At the time, it was also being discussed whether the support would be channeled through suppliers or paid directly to those eligible. The minister himself had previously admitted that past support had not always reached those who truly needed it.

The goal, then, is defensible. Anyone who has to cut back on food or medicine after paying the electricity bill needs help; and the struggles of companies crippled by energy prices also affect others, through jobs and product prices. However, when it comes to the tax levied to fund the support, it's not enough to name who transfers the money to the state. It should also be known whose pocket the money ultimately comes out of. If the new burden raises the cost of electricity production or sales, companies may try to recoup the lost money through higher selling prices. How much of this succeeds depends on competition, contracts, import options, and the design of the tax itself. So the pass-through is not automatic, and not necessarily complete, but it is a very real risk. If it happens, the state would be handing out support with one hand while possibly contributing, with the other, to making that support even more necessary.

That is precisely why it makes a crucial difference whether the government would skim off part of the windfall profit, or instead burden production or revenue in a way that fails to properly account for costs. According to an International Monetary Fund analysis of special energy taxes, a well-designed tax that truly targets excess returns can limit the adverse effects on prices and investment. A poorly designed, abruptly introduced levy, however, can hold back investment, and a tax that raises production costs can also cause further price increases. In the long run, this can just as easily backfire on consumers. If a company spends less on new capacity, or postpones an investment because of unpredictable taxation, that won't result in more or cheaper electricity. So short-term budget revenue can still have a cost later on, even if the new tax doesn't show up immediately on the next bill.

The government should therefore back the announcement of the tax with calculations: how much it wants to collect, from whom, on what basis, to whom it would pass the money on, and what price effect it expects. Supporting those in need is a legitimate goal, but on its own it doesn't justify just any financing solution. If the consumer ends up paying back part of the assistance received through more expensive energy, then the government has at best just run the money through the state treasury while issuing a few reassuring statements along the way. The bill still ends up in the consumer's hands.

Ugar

Did you like this article?

Support our work with a small donation

Secure payment via Stripe • Min. 2 EUR

Gesta recommendations:

Europe wants to replace Palantir, Musk showed why in Ukraine

Europe wants to replace Palantir, Musk showed why in Ukraine

European defense ministries want to reduce their dependence on key military tasks on the American company Palantir Technologies and other American technology firms, and an increasing number of European companies are competing for the market being vacated. Germany, France and the Netherlands are all building their own European systems for what Palantir's software has been used for or would have…

ugar•
We receive the chemicals that disrupt our hormonal system even before we are born

We receive the chemicals that disrupt our hormonal system even before we are born

Chemicals that disrupt the human hormonal system are now present almost everywhere in our environment: in plastics, cosmetics, toys and pesticides, and researchers have detected them in human blood, breast milk and umbilical cord blood. This means that exposure begins even before birth. This is revealed in a joint report by the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) and the World Health…

ugar•
Oops: NSA's secret network goes down

Oops: NSA's secret network goes down

A few days after Microsoft's worldwide outage and the flight ban that paralyzed American airports, service was also interrupted in one of the United States' most sensitive IT systems: the strictly classified internal network through which employees of the National Security Agency (NSA) share classified information went down. No connection has so far been established between the failures, and at…

ugar•
Lasconi would support an alliance between the PNL and the USR, but fears that everyone will once again want too much

Lasconi would support an alliance between the PNL and the USR, but fears that everyone will once again want too much

Elena Lasconi believes it would do Romania's right wing good if the PNL and the USR joined forces and tried to win back the trust of voters disillusioned with the parties under a new name, but she is less convinced that such an agreement could actually come about. The former USR leader explained her doubts by drawing on her own experience from her presidential campaign, recalling that in…

ugar•
20 years in the EU: Negrescu calls for a new European plan for Romania

20 years in the EU: Negrescu calls for a new European plan for Romania

Twenty years after Romania and Bulgaria joined the European Union on January 1, 2007, Victor Negrescu, the PSD vice-president of the European Parliament, says Romania needs a new European programme that unites the political class and civil society. “We need a new European project for our country, a European plan for Romania,” he said at the European Parliament's building in Brussels, at the event…

ugar•