Putin's war against America: when politicians of the attacked country work for the aggressor

Russia did not need to invent the divisions within American society: it was enough to recognize them, deepen them, and then support political actors who, for their own interests, further erode the authority of democratic institutions. Reviewing David Corn's new book, historian Laurence Saint-Gilles argues that the Russian affairs surrounding Trump are interconnected episodes of a decade-long political war, one of whose greatest successes has been convincing a significant part of Americans that the whole war is merely a fabrication.

Laurence Saint-Gilles, a historian who teaches the history of international relations at the Sorbonne, presents David Corn's book How Russia Won: Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin, and the Fight for America in a November 13 article for Desk Russie. Corn, the Washington bureau chief of Mother Jones, is a veteran investigative journalist covering American politics and national security affairs, who together with Michael Isikoff already examined Russian interference in the 2016 presidential election in the 2018 book Russian Roulette. His new book examines a longer period and a broader context: how Russian influence became a lasting factor in American domestic politics, and how its persistence was aided by those who profited politically from it. David Corn

According to Saint-Gilles, the most important achievement of Corn's work is that it links together affairs that the public has mostly come to know as separate scandals. A Russian business connection, a meeting near a campaign, a disinformation operation on social media, or an American statement echoing Putin's position can each be more easily dismissed on their own as a misunderstanding, an insignificant episode, or a partisan attack. Placed side by side, however, in Corn's interpretation they are parts of the same long-term operation, serving to weaken the United States internally, discredit its democratic institutions, and undermine the Western alliance system.

As a recent example, the historian recalls the affair surrounding Donald Trump Jr. and Bettina Anderson's wedding celebrations in the Bahamas in May. According to a ProPublica investigation, significant costs of the event series, including the rental of a private island and fireworks, were covered by Umar Kremlev, a Russian businessman close to Putin and head of the International Boxing Association. The couple acknowledged the gift but disputed its political significance. For Saint-Gilles, it is precisely the routine handling of such affairs that is telling: the relationship is presented as a personal friendship, while concerns are attributed to the ill will of opponents. The story thus turns into a debate about the motives of those asking questions rather than an examination of the nature of the relationship. ProPublica

Corn's central question is how all this could happen in a country where toughness toward Russia had previously been considered a basic requirement, especially for Republican politicians. Saint-Gilles recalls journalist Edward Luce's observation: before 2016, it would have been hard to imagine a Republican presidential candidate gaining political advantage from leniency toward the Kremlin. Yet in Trump's case, even after revelations about Russian interference, he retained his base, and in 2024 was elected president once again.

According to Corn, the explanation lies partly in the consistent denial of Russian influence. After the exposure of the 2016 operations, Trump and the MAGA camp kept insisting that the whole affair was a hoax, a story invented to bring down the president. This turned recognition of Russian interference into a matter of party allegiance: whoever spoke of it could be treated as an enemy of Trump, while whoever rejected the evidence could demonstrate loyalty to their own political community. In Corn's reading, this denial itself contributed to the success of the Russian operations, since any joint response to the attack would require at least agreement on its existence.

At the same time, it is worth clearly distinguishing the findings of official investigations from Corn's political conclusions. The Mueller report uncovered extensive and systematic Russian interference in the election, but did not establish that members of the Trump campaign criminally conspired or coordinated with the Russian government in the election operations under investigation. This was not a refutation of Russian interference. The bipartisan Senate investigation, meanwhile, laid out in detail the Russian connections surrounding the campaign's environment, including the cooperation between Paul Manafort and Konstantin Kilimnik, identified as a Russian intelligence operative. Corn builds a broader interpretation of political responsibility from these documents and further investigative findings. d3i6fh83elv35t.cloudfront.net

Saint-Gilles also addresses the difficulties of the research. According to his account, FBI staff dismissed by the Trump administration, whom Corn wanted to interview, refused to speak out of fear of retaliation or legal consequences. Some former intelligence officers spoke to him only on condition of anonymity. The book therefore relies, alongside confidential conversations, on thousands of pages of investigative material, the Mueller report, congressional documents, and the investigative work of other journalists. According to the review, much of the material's strength comes from the fact that Corn assembles a coherent, followable narrative out of information that was already accessible but scattered across the daily news cycle. In this narrative, the "gray zone war" refers to persistent hostile activity carried out below the threshold of open military conflict. It combines intelligence operations, political influence, disinformation, and the deliberate sharpening of existing social conflicts. According to Saint-Gilles's review, Corn traces the operations surrounding the 2016, 2020, and 2024 elections, the use of social media, and the newer tools of AI-assisted disinformation, including an operation referred to as Matryoshka. The actors involved include both military intelligence officers and troll networks; the IRA, the Internet Research Agency, was one of the latter.

One important political example in the book is the 2018 Trump–Putin summit in Helsinki. In Saint-Gilles's interpretation, Trump aided the Kremlin's position at the time by giving credence to Putin's denial regarding Russian interference, while questioning the findings of his own intelligence services. The scene matters in Corn's argument because it showed what happens when the leader of the attacked country himself undermines the authority of the institutions that exposed the foreign operation. However, passing on influence does not require every participant to receive direct instructions from Moscow. According to Saint-Gilles, Corn also examines the activities of MAGA opinion leaders, alternative right-wing media outlets, and American propagandists living in Russia. Some may knowingly assist the Kremlin, while others spread the same messages out of ideological sympathy, political gain, or simple opportunism. The term "fifth column," which appears in the review, refers to this internal mediating environment: actors who make Russian narratives acceptable to American audiences in an American voice.

Saint-Gilles considers one of Corn's most important insights to be that Russia typically exploits already existing social fault lines. Grievances, mistrust, and institutional failures arise locally, and the outside interferer builds on these to increase confrontation. Thus even a debate organized around a real problem can serve foreign interests if the goal of the interference is to make a solution impossible, to dismantle the common factual basis, and to instill the belief that the entire democratic system is irreparably corrupt. The French historian therefore also reads the American story as a warning for Europe. In France, the political fragmentation that followed the dissolution of the National Assembly, the coarsening of public debate, and social tensions likewise create a favorable environment for foreign interference. With the help of social media and artificial intelligence, Russian operations can amplify these conflicts, while the political community becomes increasingly less able to jointly recognize and address the external threat.

In Saint-Gilles's reading, then, the deepest meaning of the "Russian victory" in the book's title is the weakening of the attacked society's capacity for self-defense. If the investigation of foreign interference is automatically treated as a partisan attack, if the institutions exposing it become enemies, and if the Kremlin's messages are relayed by domestic politicians, then a significant part of Moscow's work is already being done by American domestic politics itself. The historian therefore presents Corn's book as the story of a political war whose success required, alongside the Russian services, the attacked country's own actors as well.

Ugar

Did you like this article?

Support our work with a small donation

Secure payment via Stripe • Min. 2 EUR

Gesta recommendations:

Cognitive Frontline, Part I/1: From the Protocols of the Elders of Zion to Today's Russian Propaganda, or the Lie That Outlived Its Own Exposure

Cognitive Frontline, Part I/1: From the Protocols of the Elders of Zion to Today's Russian Propaganda, or the Lie That Outlived Its Own Exposure

A Russian forgery from the early twentieth century made its way across the Western world. Respected newspapers, influential businessmen and political movements lent it their names, and it kept spreading even after it had been exposed. The story of the Protocols of the Elders of Zion reveals how easily a society's existing fears can be turned into a worldview that, over time, comes to explain…

ugar•
Musk Is Warned: Trump Will Leave, But the Documents Should Stay!

Musk Is Warned: Trump Will Leave, But the Documents Should Stay!

In a post-Trump era, which much of the world is awaiting with growing impatience, it may still matter who restricted Ukraine's satellite communications, why, and on whose orders, at a time when the country was under Russian air attacks. Political power has an expiration date, but electronic correspondence can have a backup copy. Two Democratic senators are now trying to make sure that by the time…

ugar•
Two Months After Taking Command, Hamas Leader May Already Get to Check the Promises of Paradise

Two Months After Taking Command, Hamas Leader May Already Get to Check the Promises of Paradise

If the promises of seventy-two virgins can be redeemed, Samir Abu Younis may now have the chance to check the quality of service. The commander of Hamas's Rafah brigade was killed by an Israeli airstrike in the early hours of November 15 in the southern Gaza Strip; his death was confirmed by the Israeli military, the Shin Bet, and Hamas itself. No statement has been issued yet about the details…

ugar•
Ships burn in Romanian territorial waters, while deterrence is being prepared for the next meeting

Ships burn in Romanian territorial waters, while deterrence is being prepared for the next meeting

Just the usual: drones slam into commercial ships at the mouth of the Danube, the crews put out the fires, Romania scrambles fighter jets, then announces that it will raise the matter at the next meeting in Brussels. This time three ships provided the set for yet another performance of the security-policy operetta titled “Now Something Really Should Be Done.” The sailors working on the decks…

ugar•
Russian bombs reached them even seven meters underground

Russian bombs reached them even seven meters underground

Ukrainians are taking their schools underground to protect children, while Russia is attacking with bombs capable of destroying even fortified shelters. Ukrainian writer Andriy Kurkov starts from this unequal struggle in his Kyiv Post opinion piece published on November 15, which uses the tragedy at Komysh-Vakha to show the limits of civilian protection as long as Russian attacks continue.

ugar•