Strasbourg: Danileț's punishment was unlawful! Savonea: I don't give a shit
Cristi Danileț has won his case for freedom of expression in Strasbourg, but has still not managed to get the Romanian court ruling that upheld his punishment overturned. The High Court of Cassation and Justice definitively rejected the former Cluj-Napoca (Kolozsvár) judge's request for a retrial on November 16, arguing that the seven-year-old sanction no longer has consequences serious enough to justify reopening the case. The institutional continuity is striking: in 2019 it was the Superior Council of Magistracy, led by Lia Savonea, that punished Danileț, and now it is the five-member panel of the High Court, also presided over by Savonea, that has rejected his request.
The story began with two Facebook posts, at a time when the PSD, led by Liviu Dragnea, was triggering mass protests by rewriting the judicial laws and attacking anti-corruption institutions. As one of the best-known defenders of judicial independence, Danileț regularly spoke out in public debates; his Facebook page was followed by about fifty thousand people, and his posts were covered by the press as well.
On January 9, 2019, he wrote about the danger of state institutions being weakened and brought under political control, then cited Article 118 of the Constitution, which lists the defense of constitutional democracy among the army's duties. The post was not just a constitutional quotation: Danileț also raised the question of what would happen if the army ever appeared on the streets to defend democracy, pointing to the constitutional possibility of such a move. The Superior Council of Magistracy (CSM) interpreted this as questioning the credibility of state institutions and as a call for military intervention. The following day, he shared an interview with Brașov prosecutor Claudiu Sandu, in which Sandu sharply criticized the government's judicial policy. Danileț praised the prosecutor using the Romanian expression that he has „sânge în instalație” – roughly meaning, in English, that he has guts. According to the CSM, this phrasing was incompatible with the propriety required of a judge. The council's judges' section cut Danileț's salary by five percent for two months, and the High Court upheld the punishment in May 2020.
Danileț then sought redress in Strasbourg. In February 2024, a chamber of the European Court of Human Rights ruled by four votes to three that Romania had violated Article 10 of the Convention, which protects freedom of expression. At Romania's request, the case was referred to the Grand Chamber, which reached the same conclusion on December 15, 2025, by ten votes to seven. This ruling is final and binding. The essence of the Strasbourg decision was that the requirement of judicial restraint does not amount to a total obligation to remain silent. Judges have the right to take part in debates of public interest, especially when democracy or the rule of law is under serious threat. According to the Grand Chamber, Danileț's statements did not upset the balance between public participation and the preservation of judicial independence and impartiality. In assessing the sanction, the chilling effect on the entire judiciary also had to be taken into account: even a relatively mild punishment can send the message to others that it is better not to speak out.
After his victory in Strasbourg, Danileț asked Romania's High Court to reopen the case and overturn the decision upholding his punishment, but the five-member civil panel rejected the request on November 16. According to the ICCJ's explanation, the finding of a violation in Strasbourg is not in itself sufficient grounds for a retrial. Under Romanian procedural rules, it must also be shown that the aggrieved party continues to suffer serious consequences that can only be remedied by reopening the case. The panel found that this condition was not met in Danileț's case: the two-month, five-percent pay cut had little impact relative to his financial situation, its effects ceased within a short time, and the sanction was later erased by operation of law. According to the statement, the original decision also had no bearing on the later disciplinary cases brought against Danileț. The High Court stresses that it is not disputing Strasbourg's finding, and that Romanian authorities must apply the requirements set out by the Grand Chamber. It thus acknowledges the violation, yet still declines to overturn the domestic ruling that upheld the unlawful punishment. The statutory erasure of the punishment, it notes, is not the same as a domestic ruling declaring that it should never have been imposed in the first place.
In his reaction on Monday afternoon, Danileț objected precisely to this distinction. In a Facebook post, he wrote that because of the decision he will not get back the salary he says was unlawfully withheld, nor the interest on it, that he cannot recover the sums he spent on lawyers and travel during the proceedings, and that the finding of disciplinary misconduct will not be erased either. In his view, an erasure tied to the mere passage of time is not the same as clearing his name. The two sides describe the state of his disciplinary record differently: the ICCJ refers to an erasure that has already taken place, while Danileț claims that the offense he says he never committed still appears on his disciplinary record. He also criticized President Nicușor Dan for, in his view, standing by idly while institutions meant to protect rights commit violations.
The 2019 pay cut was, moreover, only one of several proceedings brought against the judge. The CSM later punished him three more times with expulsion from the judiciary. The first was in December 2021, over two TikTok videos: in one he was trimming a hedge, in the other cleaning his pool. Danileț argued in vain that these were scenes from his private life; the council saw in them harm to the authority of the judiciary. In May 2022, he was expelled again over his role in the civic organizations VeDem Just and ICDE. One association focused on legal education, the other on promoting European democratic culture, but the CSM and the Judicial Inspection concluded that his public statements amounted to prohibited political activity. According to an analysis by Europa Liberă at the time, this amounted to classifying a civic organization as a political group, setting a dangerous precedent for anyone speaking out in defense of the rule of law and fundamental rights.
The third expulsion was linked to a procedural irregularity he was accused of in a drug-trafficking criminal case, which led to the defendants' release. Danileț successfully challenged several of the CSM's decisions in court: for instance, his expulsion over his activity in civic organizations was definitively overturned by a five-member panel of the High Court in February 2023, by three votes to two. He was able to return to judicial work later that same year, but retired at the beginning of 2024 after twenty-five years of service. Against this backdrop, Lia Savonea's role takes on particular weight: the same person who headed the institution that imposed the disciplinary punishment now heads the High Court that has rejected the request for a retrial. The current decision was made by the five-member panel, but that does not make the question of institutional credibility disappear. Seven years on, Danileț's case stands at the point where Strasbourg has ruled that his rights were violated, and Romania's High Court has stated that it respects this finding, yet still sees no grounds to overturn its earlier decision. There remains a significant gap between acknowledging a violation and providing redress that the person affected can actually feel.
Source
Did you like this article?
Support our work with a small donation
Secure payment via Stripe • Min. 2 EUR
Gesta recommendations:

A PNL-USR bloc would catch up with AUR
The far-right AUR remains the most popular party in Romania, but since September it has lost more than five percentage points of support, while the PSD, now in government, has gained nearly six points. According to INSCOP's November survey, a joint run by the PNL and USR would reshuffle the balance of power: their alliance would come second, and among party voters who say they will definitely…

Inflation: prices are rising faster and faster in Romania
In Octoberannual inflation in Romania rose again to nearly seven percent, and on November 16 the central bank further worsened its forecast: it now expects year-end inflation of 7.4 percent instead of the previously anticipated 6.1 percent. The cost of fuel and energy is increasingly being built into the prices of more and more goods and services, while ahead of winter, uncertainties in…

Estonia closes border crossings with Russia
Estonia will close, starting December 1, all three of its road border crossings with Russia that are still operating, after an attempt early Saturday to set fire to and blow up the Tallinn-area plant of drone maker Threod Systems. According to Estonia's internal security service, the attack was commissioned and directed by Russian military intelligence, the GRU. Eight people were detained, and…

Cognitive Frontline, Part I/1: From the Protocols of the Elders of Zion to Today's Russian Propaganda, or the Lie That Outlived Its Own Exposure
A Russian forgery from the early twentieth century made its way across the Western world. Respected newspapers, influential businessmen and political movements lent it their names, and it kept spreading even after it had been exposed. The story of the Protocols of the Elders of Zion reveals how easily a society's existing fears can be turned into a worldview that, over time, comes to explain…

Musk Is Warned: Trump Will Leave, But the Documents Should Stay!
In a post-Trump era, which much of the world is awaiting with growing impatience, it may still matter who restricted Ukraine's satellite communications, why, and on whose orders, at a time when the country was under Russian air attacks. Political power has an expiration date, but electronic correspondence can have a backup copy. Two Democratic senators are now trying to make sure that by the time…